☆ Moses: the Iran war doesn’t explain the downtown San Jose BART extension’s massive overage

 
 

The megaproject’s cost shot up 170% well before the Iran war, says municipal finance expert Mark Moses: this December, the VTA oversight committee that Mayor Mahan chairs should ask the full board, “At what price would you stop?” An Opp Now Exclusive.

VTA says the cost of its BART extension through downtown San José to Santa Clara is rising again, partly because the Iran war has driven up the price of diesel and construction materials. San José Mayor Matt Mahan notes that nobody could have predicted the war. But the cost had risen by $8 billion, or about 170 percent, before the war began. In 2014, VTA estimated the extension would cost $4.7 billion and be finished by the end of 2026. By the 2024 groundbreaking, the estimate was $12.7 billion, and the target date is now 2037. Mahan asked what else VTA could be doing so it wouldn’t be back in a year or two with “a whole new number.” Better estimates are useful, but they don’t answer the question of how much is too much. So far, no number has been high enough to stop the project.

The options now under discussion include phasing construction and deciding which stations come first. VTA’s general manager, Carolyn Gonot, says the agency remains “firmly committed to completing the entire extension.” Mahan wants to stay “committed to the full vision” but says it can’t be delivered “in one fell swoop.” That isn’t a smaller project. It’s the same project in installments. Mahan also points to residents who “voted to tax themselves.” But voting to pay for a project isn’t agreeing to pay whatever it costs. The updated estimate goes to the VTA oversight committee he chairs in late December, more than a year before tunneling is expected to begin. The committee advises, but the decision belongs to the full VTA board, where Mahan is vice chair. Before it accepts a new number, the board should answer one question on the record: At what price would you stop?

Follow Opportunity Now on X @svopportunity

We prize letters from our thoughtful readers. Typed on a Smith Corona. Written in longhand on fine stationery. Scribbled on a napkin. Hey, even composed on email. Feel free to send your comments to us at opportunitynowsv@gmail.com or (snail mail) 1590 Calaveras Ave., SJ, CA 95126. Remember to be thoughtful and polite. We will post letters on an irregular basis on the main Opp Now site.